People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Had a double scoop of coffee Oreo ice cream in a waffle cone, so good!! Hubs got a slice and a po boy, so much shrimp he had to eat some before he could close the sandwich. He said both were delicious! ”
“ Arrr, American Pie Pizza & Homemade Ice Cream be a hidden gem worthy of any hungry pirate’s chart! The pizza be oven-fired perfection—crispy crust, melty cheese, and toppings piled high like plundered treasure. But save room, matey, for the real gold: their homemade ice cream be smoother than a calm sea at sunset, with flavors so rich they’d make a captain weep with joy. The crew be friendly and fast, servin’ with smiles and treatin’ every guest like part of the ship. Whether ye be droppin’ anchor for a full meal or just sailin’ in for a sweet treat, this be a port worth revisitin’. Five parrots out of five! — From a pizza-plunderin’, ice cream-scoopin’ scallywag! ”
“ What a fantastic beach staple, a takeaway pizza and ice cream shop!! We decided to eat under the wooden canopy with ceiling fans and picnic tables. We got slices of supreme pizza which were both delicious and a side of a scoop of ice cream. The rum raisin was super creamy and not overly sweet. The coffee oreo was fabulous. The weather was beautiful and we could have sat in the big Adirondack chairs and chatted all afternoon. Super friendly service, very clean facility, with a separate bathroom house across the parking lot. We will come back again!! ”
“ My husband and I were looking for a good pizza place. We are out of towners so don't know any of the places in the area. We just looked under google maps and restaraunts. It was on the list and so we gave it a try. So glad we did! We got an extra cheese pizza with pineapple and then he got a hot fudge sundae and I had a 1 topping sundae with oreo ice cream and choc chips. The entire meal was delicious and the staff was so friendly. Would def go back again if we come back this way. ”
“ We enjoy this delightful place. Had pizza, then ice cream for dessert! Outdoor eating is perfect for me as often as I get the opportunity. Your pups are even welcome! ”
“ Great and fast pizza place in Outer Banks. Super delicious pizza! Service is also amazing. ”
“ 1000/10. Me and my boyfriend came from NY for the week and we came here to get some ice cream. The flavors available were perfect and the ice cream was so creamy. We will be coming back every night to try the other flavors. ”
“ Perfect beach hangout. The place has a great casual atmosphere, and really friendly staff. It was very clean when I came here and the pizza was fantastic! In fact, this is probably the best pizza I’ve had outside of New York. Anyone who thinks it’s too greasy doesn’t know that a good pizza should have a little extra oil on it so you can sop it up with a napkin. ”
Menu
BBQ Chicken Pizza
French Fries
Fried Popcorn Shrimp
US$12.95Fried Chicken Tenders
US$12.95Fried Shrimp Po’ Boy
US$11.95
About
American Pie Pizza & Homemade Ice Cream
Welcome to American Pie Pizza & Homemade Ice Cream, a charming culinary oasis nestled in the heart of Kill Devil Hills, NC. Located at 1600 S Virginia Dare Trail, this establishment is not just a place to eat; it’s a vibrant destination for food lovers who appreciate quality, flavor, and a welcoming atmosphere.
The moment you step inside, you are greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizzas, perfectly complemented by the sweet scents of homemade ice cream. Their specialty pizzas are a celebration of diverse flavors, each crafted with care. Try the BBQ Chicken Pizza, where grilled chicken meets BBQ sauce on a crispy crust topped with melty mozzarella. For the meat enthusiasts, the Meaty Italian Pizza offers a hearty combination of pepperoni, sausage, and ham, while the Weed Eater Pizza caters to veggie lovers with its abundance of mushrooms, black olives, onions, and green peppers.
Don’t miss the chance to explore their unique creations like the Shrimp Scampi Pizza, featuring fresh local shrimp and roasted garlic. Or, for the ultimate feast, indulge in The Big 5 Pizza, packed with toppings that are sure to satisfy any pizza craving. And if you're a cheese lover, the American Pie Extra Cheese will make your heart sing with its ooey-gooey goodness.
Of course, no meal here is complete without a side of their famous homemade ice cream. Creamy and rich, the flavors range from coffee Oreo to rum raisin, delivering a delightful ending to your pizza journey. As one satisfied customer, Naomi Blankenship, aptly put it, the ice cream “be smoother than a calm sea at sunset.” Whether you choose a classic sundae or a scoop in a freshly made waffle cone, the quality and craftsmanship shine through in every bite.
The ambiance at American Pie is equally inviting, with outdoor seating options that allow you to enjoy your meal in the fresh ocean air. Families and four-legged friends are welcomed warmly, making it a perfect spot for group gatherings. As Brooke Grimes noted in her review, they serve up generous portions—nothing like digging into a po' boy filled with succulent shrimp or crispy mahi!
In summary, American Pie Pizza & Homemade Ice Cream isn’t just a meal; it’s an experience filled with cheerful service, delicious food, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. If you find yourself in the area, be sure to stop by; it truly is a hidden gem worth visiting. Your taste buds will thank you!
Book a table